British conductor Edward Gardner has issued an apology for his controversial remarks that likened singers at Napoli’s Teatro San Carlo to rival Mafia families, which has led to the possibility of a defamation lawsuit. His comments were made after he learned of a real altercation involving chorus members, but he clarified that he did not mean to suggest any actual Mafia connections. Gardner expressed his respect for the choir and regretted implying otherwise, while local authorities and the opera house acknowledged and appreciated his retraction.
Key Points:
- Edward Gardner, the principal conductor of the London Philharmonic Orchestra, made provocative comments comparing opera singers to rival Mafia families.
- His remarks prompted threats of a defamation lawsuit from the chorus members of Teatro San Carlo in Naples.
- Gardner’s initial comments were based on a reported public altercation between two choir members.
- He publicly apologized, clarifying that there was no intention to imply that the choir members were actual Mafiosi.
- Gardner expressed deep respect for the San Carlo choir, praising their professionalism and talent.
- His comments sparked anger from the mayor of Naples, who deemed the allegations unfounded.
- The general director of Teatro San Carlo expressed gratitude for Gardner’s retraction and highlighted the importance of the ensemble.

